10 Tips for Getting Started as a Peer Reviewer

Image: Pexels (CC0)

Are you thinking about being a peer reviewer but aren’t sure where to start? Are you concerned that you don’t have enough experience to review a manuscript for a journal?

Here are ten easy things you can do to prepare to be a reviewer and put yourself in a position to start reviewing. Some of these are so simple you can do them in the next five minutes. Get started now!

Icon of a person's head next to a pencil

1. Update your public profile

Keep your department or personal website current and make sure it includes relevant keywords about your research areas.

 

Icon of binoculars

2. Be findable

Make sure your email address is easy to find and up to date.

 

Icon of a person reading a book

3. Read, read, read

Stay up to date with the published literature in your field (via journal eTOC alerts or RSS feeds, among others). When you read an article, think about how you would evaluate it if you were reviewing it for a journal. Also read articles that are published with the reviewer comments online.

 

Icon of a scroll of paper

4. Keep up the good work

Editors often select reviewers by looking at the references in published articles. By continuing to conduct your research and report the results, you’ll help editors find you, and match you to the kinds of studies you want to read.

 

Icon of ORCID logo

5. Get a unique personal identifier

Sign up for an ORCID iD and authorize ORCID to link up your publications.

 

Icon of two hands being held up

6. Find a mentor

Let your supervisor know that you are interested in doing peer review. Ask if you might be able to coauthor a review with your supervisor. Use the confidential comments section of the review form to share your name with the journal. Some journals also might have mentoring programs for junior reviewers.

 

Icon of three silhouettes

7. Go to conferences

Give presentations or participate on panels at conferences to start getting known among others in your field. Network with journal editors attending the conferences.

 

Icon of Twitter logo

8. Get active on social media

Follow and connect with experts in your field via Twitter, LinkedIn, or other platforms.

 

Icon of university building

9. Join (or start!) a journal club

Find or form a group at your university or institution to get practice evaluating research with your peers.

 

Icon of paper and pencil

10. Practice writing about research

Get involved in open peer review (e.g., F1000 Research), join preprint discussions on bioRxiv or PREreview, or add post-publication article comments on journal websites.

 

Do you have ideas or advice not listed here? Let us know!